MYP 3 Sciences · The Periodic Table

Why same-group elements are a family

Get started
Free preview 2/15
  1. Question 1

    Sodium (Na) has the electron arrangement 2, 8, 1. Which statement best explains why sodium is placed in Group 1 of the Periodic Table?
    No clue? Show me the answer
    Correct answerCorrect!Incorrect
    ASodium has 1 outer-shell electron, which determines its group number

    Step-by-step walkthrough

    Choose a solution method

    Method #1Direct Approach

    Step 1: Identify the key principle

    For main-group elements, the group number in the Periodic Table equals the number of outer-shell (valence) electrons in each atom.

    Step 2: Count sodium's outer-shell electrons

    Sodium's electron arrangement is 2, 8, 1. The last number, 1, tells us there is 1 electron in the outermost shell.

    Step 3: Link outer electrons to group number

    Because sodium has 1 outer-shell electron, it belongs in Group 1. This is exactly why elements in Group 1 all behave similarly — they all have 1 outer electron.

    Step 4: Select the correct answer

    The correct answer is: Sodium has 1 outer-shell electron, which determines its group number.

    Method #2Process of Elimination

    Step 1: Identify what the question asks

    The question asks why sodium is in Group 1 — so we need the answer that correctly links atomic structure to group placement.

    Step 2: Eliminate 'all metals are in Group 1'

    The option 'Sodium is a metal, and all metals are placed in Group 1' is wrong. Many metals (iron, copper, gold) are in completely different groups — the transition metals, for example.

    Step 3: Eliminate the 'three electron shells' option

    'Sodium has 3 electron shells, so it belongs in the first group' is wrong. The number of shells tells you the period (horizontal row), not the group.

    Step 4: Eliminate the arithmetic option

    'Sodium has 11 protons in total, and 1 + 1 = 2, so it is in Period 2' is nonsensical arithmetic with no chemical basis.

    Step 5: Select the correct answer

    The remaining option — Sodium has 1 outer-shell electron, which determines its group number — is correct and reflects the key principle of group chemistry.

  2. Question 2

    Chlorine (Cl) is in Group 7 and is a highly reactive non-metal gas. Bromine (Br) is directly below chlorine in Group 7. Which prediction about bromine is most accurate?
    No clue? Show me the answer
    Correct answerCorrect!Incorrect
    ABromine will be less reactive than chlorine because its outer electron shell is further from the nucleus and holds electrons more loosely

    Step-by-step walkthrough

    Choose a solution method

    Method #1Direct Approach

    Step 1: Identify Group 7's reactivity trend

    In Group 7, reactivity decreases going down the group. Fluorine is most reactive, then chlorine, then bromine, and iodine is least reactive of the four.

    Step 2: Explain the trend using atomic structure

    Halogens react by gaining one electron to complete their outer shell. Going down Group 7, each element has more electron shells, so the outer shell is further from the nucleus. This means the nucleus attracts an incoming electron less strongly, making it harder to gain that electron — so reactivity decreases.

    Step 3: Apply to bromine

    Bromine is below chlorine in Group 7, so its outer shell is further from the nucleus. It is less reactive than chlorine.

    Step 4: Select the correct answer

    The correct answer is: Bromine will be less reactive than chlorine because its outer electron shell is further from the nucleus and holds electrons more loosely.

    Method #2Process of Elimination

    Step 1: Identify what the question asks

    We need the most accurate prediction about bromine's reactivity compared to chlorine, using knowledge of Group 7 trends.

    Step 2: Eliminate 'more reactive because more electrons'

    'More reactive because it has more electrons overall' is wrong. Total electron count is irrelevant — it's the outer-shell electron behaviour that determines reactivity.

    Step 3: Eliminate 'full outer shell'

    'Less reactive because it has a full outer shell' is wrong. Halogens have 7 outer electrons — one short of a full shell. It's the noble gases that have a full outer shell.

    Step 4: Eliminate 'identical reactivity'

    'Identical reactivity because they are in the same group' is wrong. Same-group elements share the type of reaction, but there are gradual trends in reactivity within a group.

    Step 5: Select the correct answer

    The correct answer is that bromine is less reactive than chlorine, with the correct explanation that the outer shell is further from the nucleus — matching the Group 7 trend.

Free preview

13 more questions in this topic

Pick this up in your Library: it holds the whole topic, notes, cheatsheet and questions. Your answers here are kept on this device.