
Your Physics Internal Assessment results are only 3% different from the theoretical prediction. Is that suspiciously accurate? What if the difference is 15% instead? Could either result reduce your IA marks?
A February 2026 r/IBO discussion raised this concern after a student obtained projectile motion measurements that differed from theory by approximately 3%. The student worried that unusually close agreement might appear fabricated.
The important distinction is that agreement with theory is not the same as experimental quality. A close result can be legitimate, while a substantial difference can reveal meaningful limitations in a physical model or experimental method.
What matters is whether your data are authentic, your calculations are accurate and your conclusions are supported by an appropriate treatment of uncertainty.
What Does the IB Physics IA Actually Assess?
The IB Physics curriculum emphasises experimental investigation, quantitative analysis and understanding the limitations of scientific knowledge.
Under the Physics guide for first assessment in 2025, the scientific investigation contributes 20% of the final Physics grade at both SL and HL.
It has a maximum report length of 3,000 words and is assessed out of 24 marks.
| Assessment criterion | Marks | What matters |
|---|---|---|
| Research design | 6 | Focused question, justified methodology and reproducibility |
| Data analysis | 6 | Accurate processing, appropriate uncertainties and clear presentation |
| Conclusion | 6 | A justified answer compared with accepted scientific knowledge |
| Evaluation | 6 | Specific limitations, their relative impact and realistic improvements |
There is no assessment requirement that your experimental value must fall within a particular percentage of theory.
A 3% difference is not inherently better than a 10% difference. The significance of either depends on the experiment, measurement uncertainty and validity of the theoretical model.
Start by Understanding Why Theory and Experiment Differ
Physics models describe relationships under specified assumptions. Experiments take place under real conditions that may not satisfy those assumptions perfectly.
For example, a simple pendulum model assumes a small angular displacement, negligible damping and an effectively pointlike bob suspended from a light string.
A real pendulum may experience air resistance, pivot friction, finite amplitude effects and uncertainty in its effective length.
Three questions should guide your analysis:
- What does the theoretical model predict under the conditions tested?
- How large is the difference between the prediction and the measured result?
- Is that difference meaningful relative to the uncertainty and limitations of the investigation?
Answering all three is more informative than reporting percentage error alone.
Worked Example: Comparing Experimental and Theoretical Values
Consider a hypothetical pendulum experiment designed to estimate gravitational acceleration.
For small oscillations, the theoretical relationship is:
T = 2π√(L/g)
Rearranging gives:
g = 4π²L / T²
Suppose the following values were obtained:
| Quantity | Illustrative value |
|---|---|
| Pendulum length, L | 0.800 m |
| Standard uncertainty in length | 0.005 m |
| Period, T | 1.82 s |
| Standard uncertainty in period | 0.03 s |
| Reference gravitational acceleration | 9.81 m/s² |
These are invented teaching measurements, not experimental observations. For simplicity, the stated uncertainties are assumed to be independent standard uncertainties.
Substituting into the equation:
g = 4π²(0.800) / (1.82)²
This gives:
Experimental g = 9.53 m/s²
Using 9.81 m/s² as the nominal reference:
Percentage error = |9.53 − 9.81| / 9.81 × 100
The result is approximately 2.8%.
The reference is a rounded conventional value. The actual local gravitational acceleration varies geographically, so highly precise comparisons require an appropriate local reference. The US National Institute of Standards and Technology lists the conventional standard acceleration of gravity as 9.80665 m/s².
Does the 2.8% difference establish excellent accuracy? Not by itself. We must first calculate and interpret the experimental uncertainty.
How to Propagate Uncertainties Correctly
For the pendulum relationship, gravitational acceleration depends on length and the square of the period.
Assuming small, independent standard uncertainties, the approximate relative combined uncertainty is:
u(g)/g = √[(u(L)/L)² + (2u(T)/T)²]
Substituting the illustrative measurements gives a relative standard uncertainty of approximately 3.36%.
The absolute standard uncertainty is therefore:
u(g) ≈ 9.53 × 0.0336 = 0.32 m/s²
Our processed result becomes:
g = (9.53 ± 0.32) m/s²
The nominal reference value of 9.81 m/s² lies within this stated standard uncertainty interval.
This indicates that the observed discrepancy is small relative to the estimated measurement uncertainty. It does not prove that the theoretical model is correct or that systematic errors are absent.
The procedure follows the general NIST law of propagation of uncertainty. The correct method depends on the measurement equation, uncertainty definitions and correlations between inputs.
Do not treat an instrument's smallest scale division, the spread of repeated measurements and the uncertainty of a calculated mean as interchangeable quantities.
What If Your Result Differs Substantially From Theory?
Now imagine a separate hypothetical pendulum measurement using the same length but a period of 1.96 s, with the same illustrative standard uncertainties.
The calculated gravitational acceleration becomes approximately:
g = (8.22 ± 0.26) m/s²
This is about 16.2% below the nominal reference of 9.81 m/s².
The discrepancy is substantially larger than the stated standard uncertainty. This suggests that the proposed uncertainty model, experimental procedure or theoretical assumptions need closer examination.
Possible explanations include an incorrect effective length, timing bias, excessive oscillation amplitude or overlooked apparatus effects.
These are hypotheses to investigate, not reasons to automatically discard the result.
If repeated measurements consistently produce a similar discrepancy, investigate systematic effects. If repeated values fluctuate widely, assess repeatability and random variation.
Neither situation justifies changing measurements to produce a more attractive theoretical agreement.
Use Graphs to Compare Theory and Experiment
Graphs often provide stronger evidence than comparing one calculated value with a reference.
For the simple pendulum:
T² = (4π²/g)L
Plotting squared period against pendulum length should produce an approximately straight line when the model's assumptions hold.
The theoretical gradient for a nominal gravitational acceleration of 9.81 m/s² is approximately:
4.02 s²/m
Your experimental gradient can be used to estimate gravitational acceleration and compared with this prediction.
A useful graph should include clearly labelled axes, units, individual data points, appropriate error bars and a justified best fit.
Examine whether the points follow the predicted relationship, whether residuals reveal a pattern and whether the fitted intercept is consistent with expectations.
A nonzero intercept may indicate a methodological problem or model limitation, but it does not automatically identify the cause. You need to examine its magnitude, uncertainty and physical interpretation.
For experiments involving resistance, projectile motion or energy transfer, choose a graph that tests the relevant theoretical relationship rather than assuming every dataset should form a straight line.
Understand Random and Systematic Errors
The distinction between random and systematic effects is central to IB Physics IA data analysis.
| Type | Possible pendulum example | Effect on results |
|---|---|---|
| Random variation | Inconsistent manual reaction times | Produces variation between repeated measurements |
| Systematic effect | Consistently measuring length to the bottom of the bob rather than its centre | Can bias the calculated gravitational acceleration |
| Instrument limitation | Timing resolution too coarse for the required precision | Limits the detail that can reliably be measured |
| Model limitation | Using the small angle equation for large oscillations | Can create disagreement with the simplified theoretical prediction |
Taking more measurements can improve estimates of random variation and reduce the random uncertainty of a mean.
However, additional repeats do not automatically eliminate systematic effects.
For example, repeating a timing measurement twenty times will not correct a consistently mismeasured pendulum length.
The evaluation should therefore distinguish between improvements that increase precision and those that improve accuracy or model validity.
How to Write a Strong Physics IA Evaluation
The highest Evaluation descriptor in the official guide rewards explanation of the relative impact of specific methodological weaknesses, together with realistic improvements.
Avoid generic statements such as "human error affected the experiment."
Instead, connect the limitation to its likely effect on your final result.
| Limitation | Potential impact | Specific improvement |
|---|---|---|
| Manual stopwatch timing | Reaction time variation may increase uncertainty in the period | Use an appropriate photogate or electronic timing system |
| Incorrect effective pendulum length | Creates systematic bias in the calculated value of g | Measure from the pivot to the bob's centre of mass |
| Large oscillation amplitude | Violates the assumptions of the small angle model | Use and document sufficiently small initial angles |
| Limited range of lengths | Makes the fitted gradient less precisely determined | Test a wider justified range of pendulum lengths |
These are potential limitations, not confirmed faults in the hypothetical example.
Prioritise improvements according to their expected effect. There is little value in proposing a more precise ruler if timing uncertainty dominates the calculation.
Likewise, when equipment improvements are impractical, describe a realistic method of identifying or estimating the limitation rather than promising perfect measurements.
Is a Result Only 3% From Theory Suspicious?
No. A small difference from theory is not evidence of fabrication.
A well controlled experiment testing a reliable physical relationship may naturally produce close agreement. What matters for authenticity is whether the student genuinely collected and processed the measurements.
The IB Physics guide requires submitted IA work to be authentic and properly referenced.
Students should preserve original readings, retain relevant records and document legitimate corrections or exclusions.
Do not invent variation to make results appear more realistic. Equally, do not remove inconvenient measurements, alter values or select only trials that support the expected relationship.
An honest dataset with close agreement may support a strong investigation. An honest dataset with substantial disagreement can also support a valuable scientific conclusion.
How to Write Your Conclusion Without Overclaiming
Your conclusion should answer the research question, state the measured relationship or value, incorporate uncertainty and compare the result with accepted physics.
For the first illustrative pendulum example, a suitable interpretation would be:
"The experimental estimate of gravitational acceleration was (9.53 ± 0.32) m/s². This was approximately 2.8% below the nominal reference value of 9.81 m/s². The difference was smaller than the estimated standard uncertainty, indicating that the measurement is reasonably compatible with the reference under the stated uncertainty assumptions. Possible systematic effects and limitations of the pendulum model require further consideration."
This example demonstrates scientific reasoning using hypothetical measurements. It is not a conclusion to submit as original experimental work.
For your actual IA, explain the specific limitations supported by your observations and cite any theoretical relationships or reference values used.
Final Physics IA Data Analysis Checklist
Before submitting your scientific investigation, verify that you have:
- Preserved authentic raw measurements and documented any exclusions.
- Identified the theoretical relationship and its assumptions.
- Calculated experimental values with correct units and significant figures.
- Compared results using appropriate percentage differences and uncertainties.
- Propagated uncertainties using a method suited to the measured quantities.
- Used graphs and fitted relationships where they contribute meaningful evidence.
- Distinguished random variation, systematic effects and model limitations.
- Explained realistic improvements based on their relative impact.
The goal of your Physics IA is not to reproduce a textbook number perfectly. It is to demonstrate how confidently your measurements support a physical explanation.
Whether your results differ from theory by 3% or 16%, the strongest analysis makes that difference understandable, evaluates its importance and remains faithful to the evidence.
Table of contents
Share
Related reading
- IB Physics IA Criteria: How Strong Reports Earn MarksLearn the current IB Physics IA criteria, uncertainty treatment, structure and evaluation standards to build a clearer, stronger scientific investigation.
- IB Physics Paper 1B: Data Analysis and Graph QuestionsPrepare for IB Physics Paper 1B with worked graph and uncertainty questions, experimental design tips, data analysis and practical strategies for exam day.
- IB Math AI HL Paper 3: Modelling and Graph Theory GuidePrepare for IB Math AI HL Paper 3 with graph theory and Markov chain examples, practical modelling methods, GDC guidance and evaluation tips. Read the guide.
