MYP 5 Language & Literature · What Am I Responsible For?

Graphic novel conventions

Get started
Free preview 2/15
  1. Question 1

    A graphic novel page shows a character smiling and saying 'I'm fine' in a speech balloon, while a thought bubble above her head reveals 'I can't breathe, I need to get out of here.' Which image-text relationship does this best demonstrate?
    No clue? Show me the answer
    Correct answerCorrect!Incorrect
    AParallel or contradictory, because the spoken words and inner thought reveal two opposing emotional truths

    Step-by-step walkthrough

    Choose a solution method

    Method #1Direct reasoning

    Step 1: Locate the two channels

    The speech balloon says 'I'm fine' while the thought bubble reveals panic and a wish to escape.

    Step 2: Compare the two messages

    These two messages directly oppose each other rather than repeating or adding to one another.

    Step 3: Match to the table of relationships

    A relationship where text and image (or two text elements) say opposite things is defined as parallel/contradictory.

    Step 4: Confirm the answer

    The contrast between spoken calm and inner panic is exactly this contradictory relationship, producing dramatic irony.

    Method #2Process of elimination

    Step 1: Duo-specific fails

    Duo-specific requires reinforcement of the same meaning, but the speech and thought directly conflict.

    Step 2: Additive fails

    Additive would mean the thought simply supplies missing details, not an opposing emotional state.

    Step 3: Interdependent fails

    Interdependent applies when neither part makes sense alone, but here both the speech and thought are independently clear.

    Step 4: Confirm correct option

    Parallel/contradictory is the only relationship that captures two conflicting messages appearing at once.

  2. Question 2

    In a graphic novel page, a caption box at the top reads 'Three years later, none of us had spoken again.' Which feature of caption boxes does this example best illustrate?
    No clue? Show me the answer
    Correct answerCorrect!Incorrect
    BCaptions can step outside the story world to give narration about time, place, or commentary

    Step-by-step walkthrough

    Choose a solution method

    Method #1Direct reasoning

    Step 1: Identify the convention

    A rectangular box not attached to any character, giving a time jump, is a caption box.

    Step 2: Recall its function

    Captions provide narration from outside the immediate scene, often supplying time, place, or commentary.

    Step 3: Apply to the example

    'Three years later' is exactly this kind of narratorial time marker, not a character's private thought.

    Step 4: Confirm the answer

    This matches the definition of a caption box stepping outside the story world.

    Method #2Process of elimination

    Step 1: Thought bubble description fails

    That description belongs to thought bubbles, not caption boxes, since captions are not tied to one mind.

    Step 2: Speech balloon description fails

    Attachment to a mouth describes speech balloons, which show aloud dialogue, not narration.

    Step 3: Contradiction claim fails

    Captions do not always contradict the image; here the caption simply narrates elapsed time.

    Step 4: Confirm correct option

    Only the option describing external narration correctly explains this caption's role.

Free preview

13 more questions in this topic

Pick this up in your Library: it holds the whole topic, notes, cheatsheet and questions. Your answers here are kept on this device.